The Paradox of Faith and Christian Nationalism 

Reconciling Worship with Divisive Ideology 

How can some white Christians gather to sing hymns? They hear Scripture and proclaim the love of Christ. Yet, they hold to Christian nationalism. This is a divisive ideology contrary to the very heart of God. This question is as compelling as it is troubling. Christianity is a message of love, inclusion, and humility. It is taught by a Savior who broke barriers and challenged oppressors. He also welcomed the marginalized. Yet, Christian nationalism seeks to elevate one group above others. It intertwines faith with political power. Often, it leaves behind the essence of Christ’s teachings.

Understanding Christian Nationalism 

Christian nationalism is the belief that the United States was founded as a Christian nation. Its laws, policies, and culture should reflect a specific interpretation of Christianity. Patriotism focuses on pride in one’s country. Christian nationalism, yet, merges faith with a political identity. It often excludes those who do not conform to its religious or cultural standards. 

Among its defining traits are: 

• Prioritizing a particular vision of Christianity as central to national identity 

• Excluding or marginalizing other religions, cultures, and identities 

• Using faith to justify political power and policies rather than seeking justice and compassion 

Christian nationalism often diverges from the principles of humility, mercy, and love that define Christ’s teachings. Instead, it can wield faith as a weapon or tool of exclusion. 

The Heart of God versus Divisive Ideologies 

The teachings of the Gospel are clear: God’s love transcends borders, races, and national identities. The life of Christ exemplified this through His willingness to engage with Samaritans. He healed Gentiles and challenged societal norms that oppressed the vulnerable. In contrast, Christian nationalism often clings to power structures that elevate privilege rather than promote equity. 

The Bible warns against placing worldly power above divine calling: 

• Micah 6:8 reminds believers to “act justly, love mercy, and walk humbly with your God.” 

• Colossians 3:11 states, “Here there is no Gentile or Jew… but Christ is all, and is in all.” 

Christian nationalism’s focus on exclusivity and supremacy runs counter to such verses. It creates a tension between what Scripture teaches and what this ideology promotes. 

Why the Disconnect? 

The disconnect between Christian practice and Christian nationalism can stem from several factors: 

• Cultural Identity: For many white Christians, faith is deeply tied to cultural traditions and national pride. This fusion can obscure the universal and inclusive nature of Christianity. It replaces it with a version that aligns with personal biases. 

• Fear and Protectionism: The world is changing rapidly. In such times, Christian nationalism can feel like a shield. It protects against perceived threats to identity and values. This fear can lead to an inward focus, prioritizing preservation over engagement. 

• Misinterpretation of Scripture: Selective reading of the Bible can justify exclusionary practices, ignoring broader themes of love, justice, and humility. 

• Political Influence: Leaders who promote Christian nationalism often use religious rhetoric to garner support. They blend faith with political ambition. This creates confusion about the true essence of Christianity. 

Reconciling Faith with Love 

For those grappling with these contradictions, the path forward involves returning to the essence of the Gospel. Christians are called to love their neighbors, welcome the stranger, and work toward justice. These principles are incompatible with ideologies that exclude or divide. 

Steps toward reconciliation include: 

• Examining Personal Beliefs: Individuals must confront biases. They should ask whether their understanding of faith aligns with Christ’s teachings of love and humility. 

• Seeking Community and Dialogue: Engaging with diverse groups allows Christians to better understand and practice inclusivity. 

• Revisiting Scripture: Reading the Bible holistically, rather than selectively, ensures that its life-changing and inclusive message is upheld. 

• Holding Leaders Accountable: It is vital to challenge political and religious leaders who misuse faith to advance divisive agendas. 

The Call to Authentic Faith 

Authentic Christianity calls believers to transcend nationalism and embrace the universal scope of God’s love. In the kingdom of God, there are no hierarchies, no borders, and no exclusions. White Christians, like all followers of Christ, are tasked with embodying this truth. They must reject ideologies that promote division. Additionally, they should work tirelessly to reflect the grace and mercy of God. 

The paradox of worshipping Christ while adhering to Christian nationalism is not insurmountable. Believers can bridge the gap between their faith and their practices through introspection. Education and a renewed commitment to the Gospel are also crucial. They move toward the heart of God—a heart that beats for justice, unity, and unconditional love. 

Blessings,

Minister A. Francine Green