A Layman’s Guide to Heschel’s Profound Concept
Imagine God not as a distant, untouchable figure watching the world from afar. Envision God as someone who feels deeply. God grieves over human suffering. God is outraged by injustice and is moved by compassion. This is the essence of “Divine Pathos,” a concept developed by the Jewish theologian Abraham Joshua Heschel.1 Let’s break it down into simple terms.
What Is Divine Pathos?
At its core, Divine Pathos is about God’s emotional connection to the world. Heschel challenges the traditional belief that God is impassible. This means God can’t feel emotions or be affected by anything outside of Himself. Instead, Heschel portrays God as profoundly engaged with humanity, feeling emotions like we do. When humans experience joy, pain, or loss, God is not indifferent; He feels it too.
Heschel’s Argument
Heschel based this idea on the writings of the Hebrew prophets in the Bible. These prophets were not fortune-tellers trying to predict the future. They were people deeply connected to God, entrusted with revealing how God feels about the state of the world. Heschel argued that God experiences a sense of pathos—a passionate concern and sorrow for the brokenness around us.
Think of it this way: when we see someone suffering, we feel sadness or compassion. According to Heschel, God also feels deeply when He sees human suffering, cruelty, or injustice. God’s reactions—whether it’s anger or anguish—are rooted in His love and concern for humanity, not in detachment or cold judgment.
How Prophets Explained God’s Emotions
Heschel highlighted how the prophets portrayed God in deeply emotional ways. For example, God’s anger is often shown in the Bible. Heschel suggested that this anger isn’t like human rage or hostility. Instead, it’s suffering—a response to the pain caused by human actions. When people commit injustice or hurt others, God’s anger reflects His heartbreak over the consequences of those choices.
Prophets like Jeremiah and Isaiah didn’t just deliver God’s words—they expressed His emotions. Jeremiah talks about God’s grief over the suffering of His people, while Isaiah conveys God’s compassion and longing for justice. The prophets didn’t see God’s anger or sorrow as flaws. They viewed them as signs of His deep care for the world and its inhabitants.
Challenging Traditional Views of God
In many theological traditions, there’s the idea that God is impassible. This means His divine nature makes Him immune to emotions or external influences. Heschel’s concept of Divine Pathos challenges this idea. He argued that the impassibility of God—His supposed inability to feel—is inconsistent with the way the Bible describes Him.
For Heschel, a God who is emotionally disconnected wouldn’t be the God revealed by the prophets. Instead, Heschel paints a picture of God. God passionately engages with humanity. He rejoices in our triumphs and grieves over our failures.
Why Does This Matter?
Heschel’s idea of Divine Pathos has significant implications for how we think about God and our relationship with Him. It changes the way we see God. He is not an abstract, distant deity. He is a being who cares deeply about us. When we suffer, we’re not alone; God is with us, feeling our pain and longing for our healing.
This concept also reframes how we understand God’s love and justice. If God is emotionally invested in humanity, then His commands for justice, compassion, and mercy are not mere rules. They represent more than just rules to follow. They’re expressions of His heart. When we act unjustly, we hurt not only other people but also God Himself.
Connections to the New Testament
Heschel’s Divine Pathos resonates with Christian theology, particularly in the New Testament’s portrayal of Jesus. Jesus is described as someone who embodies compassion, anger, and sorrow. He weeps for Lazarus, feels anguish in the Garden of Gethsemane, and expresses righteous anger in the temple. In many ways, Jesus symbolizes the ultimate example of Divine Pathos—a God who feels deeply and connects emotionally with humanity.
Beyond Intellect: God’s Emotional Side
Heschel’s concept reminds us that God is more than an intellectual idea or a theoretical being. Divine Pathos highlights God’s emotional side—His ability to feel and care deeply for creation. This makes God more relatable and accessible. It is especially helpful for those who struggle to understand Him as a remote or purely rational figure.
In a world filled with suffering and injustice, Heschel’s idea brings comfort. It assures us that God is not indifferent to our struggles. Instead, He grieves with us, feels compassion for us, and longs for a better, more just world.
Final Thoughts
Divine Pathos is a revolutionary concept. It invites us to see God in a new light. God is seen as someone emotionally connected to humanity’s joys and sorrows. It challenges traditional views of an impassible God and emphasizes His passionate engagement with the world. Through the lens of Heschel’s insights, we understand that God’s emotions are not a sign of weakness. They are a testament to His boundless love for creation.
In the end, Heschel’s idea reminds us that we are not alone in facing life’s challenges. God walks alongside us. He shares in our triumphs and tragedies. He guides us toward a world filled with justice, compassion, and hope.
Minister A. Francine Green
June 2025
FootNotes:
Abraham J. Heschel, The Prophets (New York: HarperCollins, 1962)1
afrancinegreen.com 