Making Fairness the Heart of Justice
“Justice and only justice shall you pursue.” ( Deut. 16:20)
Imagine going to court and not knowing if the person deciding your case is rooting for one team over another. It’s a bit like playing a game where the referee has already picked a favorite. Would you trust the outcome? Most of us wouldn’t. That’s why, in simple terms, the judicial system—the courts, judges, and all those who interpret and apply the law—should be nonpartisan. In other words, they should not take sides based on politics or personal beliefs. Instead, their goal should be to deliver justice as fairly and equally as possible.
What Does “Nonpartisan” Mean?
First, let’s break down the word “nonpartisan.” “Partisan” refers to supporting a particular political party or cause. When something is “nonpartisan,” it doesn’t favor any group, party, or ideology. It stands apart from politics and personal interests. In the context of the judicial system, being nonpartisan means judges and courts decide cases based purely on the law and the facts presented—not on who has more political power or what party is in charge.
Why Is a Nonpartisan Judicial System Important?
At its core, the legal system is supposed to be a place where everyone—no matter who they are—can expect to be treated fairly. This idea is sometimes called “justice as fairness.” If the courts were partisan, it would mean some people might get better treatment than others just because of their political beliefs, connections, or influence. That isn’t justice.
· Everyone Gets a Fair Shot: Imagine two people go to court with the same problem. If the judge favors one because they belong to the “right” party, the other is at a disadvantage before the case even begins. Nonpartisan judges ensure that everyone stands on equal ground.
· Trust in the System: People are more likely to respect and follow the law when they believe the courts are fair and unbiased. If the system seems rigged, trust erodes, and people may feel justified in ignoring the law or taking matters into their own hands.
· Protecting Rights for All: A nonpartisan system doesn’t shift with the political winds. Your rights don’t depend on who’s in power. This consistency is crucial for protecting everyone’s freedom and dignity.
Justice as Fairness: The Basic Principle
The philosopher John Rawls famously argued for “justice as fairness.” He believed that fairness should be the foundation of any just society. In a fair system, people would agree to rules without knowing how those rules might benefit or hurt them personally. The idea is to remove bias and self-interest from the equation—to make rules that we would all accept, even if we didn’t know what place we’d have in the system.
When applied to the judicial system, this means judges and courts should treat every person as if they didn’t know their background, connections, or beliefs. Every case deserves an impartial ear and a fair outcome.
What Happens When the Courts Become Partisan?
When the judicial system gets tangled up in politics, several problems arise:
· Decisions May Be Biased: If a judge is seen as loyal to a particular party or ideology, their decisions may seem (or actually be) slanted in favor of that side—even if they try to be fair.
· Unequal Outcomes: Those connected to the “in group” might get special treatment, while others face harsher penalties or lose cases on unfair grounds.
· Erosion of Public Trust: People start to believe that outcomes depend on political connections rather than the merits of their case. This loss of faith can make the whole system look illegitimate.
· Unpredictable Justice: If judges change their rulings based on who’s in power, the law becomes unpredictable. People can’t be sure what’s legal or illegal from one government to the next.
Real-World Examples
Across the world, we’ve seen what happens when courts become too political. In some countries, judges are openly allied with those in power, and people fear going to court because they know the outcome is already decided. Corruption, bribery, and injustice flourish in these environments. Even in places where the judicial system is meant to be independent, the mere perception of bias can damage its reputation and effectiveness.
How Can We Keep the Judicial System Nonpartisan?
· Appointing Judges Based on Merit: Judges should be chosen for their legal knowledge, experience, and commitment to fairness—not because of their political connections.
· Lifetime or Long-Term Appointments: Giving judges secure jobs means they’re less likely to rule in ways that please politicians just to keep their position.
· Clear Ethical Standards: Judges should follow strict codes of conduct that require impartiality and recusal from cases where they might have a conflict of interest.
· Public Accountability: Systems for reviewing and, if necessary, removing judges who show blatant bias or corruption help maintain trust in the system.
· Education and Awareness: Teaching the public and future judges about the importance of impartiality helps reinforce nonpartisan values.
Why It Matters to You
This isn’t just a problem for lawyers or politicians. The fairness of the judicial system touches everyone’s lives—whether you find yourself in court or not. Laws affect our jobs, our families, our homes, and our basic freedoms. If the courts aren’t fair, anyone can become a victim of injustice.
Let’s say you’re accused of something you didn’t do. Would you rather face a judge who makes decisions based on the law, or one who listens to the loudest political voices? The answer is obvious. We all want—and deserve—a system where our fates aren’t tied to party politics.
Justice That Stands the Test of Time
Laws and governments come and go, but justice as fairness must endure. A nonpartisan judicial system is the backbone of a healthy democracy. It acts as a referee, making sure the rules are followed by everyone, no matter their status. It protects the minority from the majority and the individual from the state. Without impartial courts, democracy is at risk.
Conclusion
In simple terms: Justice is about playing fair, and the only way to ensure fairness is to keep politics out of the courtroom. Every person, regardless of who they are or what they believe, should have equal standing before the law. When our judicial system is nonpartisan, it embodies the spirit of justice as fairness—protecting rights, upholding the law, and earning the trust of all people.
We all have a stake in keeping the courts impartial. When the judicial system is truly nonpartisan, justice doesn’t just belong to some—it belongs to everyone.
afrancinegreen.com 