The Dangers of Wrapping the Gospel Message in the American Flag

Why Confusing Faith and National Identity Can Be Harmful

The Great Evangelical Disaster, Francis Schaeffer warned that “we must stand against those who would naively baptize all in the past and that would wrap Christianity in the country’s flag.”¹

When you walk into a church and see the American flag next to the pulpit, it’s easy to get a warm feeling of pride. For many, faith and country are two of the most important things in their lives, so it seems natural to put them together. But there’s a hidden danger in wrapping the gospel—the message of Jesus Christ—in the stars and stripes. Let’s break down why this is a problem, using clear and simple language.

What Does “Wrapping the Gospel in the American Flag” Mean?

First, let’s explain the phrase. When people say you’re “wrapping the gospel in the American flag,” they mean you’re mixing up Christianity with patriotism, or treating the message of Jesus as if it’s the same as being an American. It often happens when churches celebrate national holidays like the Fourth of July or Veterans Day with the same excitement as Christmas or Easter, or when pastors talk about America as a “Christian nation” and tie Bible teachings directly to American politics.

On its own, loving your country isn’t a bad thing. Being grateful for freedom and wanting to make your country better are good values. But problems start when we act as though God’s message is just for America, or that following Jesus means supporting a certain nation or political party.

Why Is This Dangerous?

Let’s look at some reasons why mixing the gospel with nationalism (putting your country first before anything else) is risky:

1. The Gospel Is for Everyone, Not Just Americans

Jesus’ message was about love, forgiveness, and hope—for all people, everywhere. When we start to act as though Christianity is an “American religion,” we forget that Jesus was born in the Middle East, and his followers come from every country, tribe, and language. The Bible says God “so loved the world,” not just one country (John 3:16). Mixing up faith with patriotism can make people in other countries feel like outsiders, even though the gospel is meant for them too.

2. It Confuses the Mission of the Church

The main job of the church is to share the love and teachings of Jesus, help people grow in faith, and serve those in need. When churches focus too much on national pride, their true mission can get sidetracked. Some people may start to think being a “good Christian” is the same as being a “good American,” or that the church’s main job is to support the country instead of helping people find hope, forgiveness, and a relationship with God.

3. It Can Lead to Division

Not everyone in a church may have the same political views or even be from the same country. When we wrap the gospel in national symbols, it can make people who feel differently left out or unimportant. It can also drive wedges between Christians, when there should be unity. The Bible says the church is like a family made up of all kinds of people. Mixing politics and faith too much can hurt that family feeling.

4. It Sends the Wrong Message to Outsiders

Imagine you’re not a Christian, or you’re new to church. If the first thing you see is an American flag and hear about how God blesses America, you might think, “Is this place only for Americans? Does God love people from other countries less?” Or, you might think the church cares more about politics than about God. This can keep people away from Jesus, which is the opposite of what the church is supposed to do.

5. It Risks Turning Faith Into a Political Tool

History shows that whenever religion and politics get mixed up, someone usually tries to use faith for their own gain. If the church gets too close to politics, politicians might use religious language to get votes, or churches might take sides in debates that have little to do with Jesus’ message. This makes it easy for people to lose trust in the church, or to get confused about what it really means to follow Jesus.

6. It Makes the Gospel Small

The message of Jesus is huge—it’s about changing lives, healing hearts, and giving hope to all people. When we tie the gospel too closely to one country’s flag, we’re making it smaller than it really is. God’s love is much bigger than any one nation or race or language.

Real-Life Examples

To make this concrete, here are a few situations that show the problems with wrapping the gospel in the flag:

· Church services as political rallies: Some churches spend more time talking about the latest election than about Jesus. This can make faith seem just like another part of politics, instead of something bigger and deeper.

· Confusing religious symbols with national ones: When a cross and a flag are side by side, it can be hard to tell what comes first. Are we pledging our loyalty to God, or to a country?

· Excluding others: Immigrants, visitors from other countries, or people with different political views might feel unwelcome if the church seems to care more about being American than about being like Jesus.

What’s the Right Balance?

So, should Christians ignore their country? Not at all! The Bible talks about praying for leaders and being good citizens. But it also warns against making anything—even a nation—more important than God. The key is to keep faith and patriotism in their proper places.

· Love your country, but don’t worship it. Give thanks for your freedoms, but remember they don’t come before your faith.

· Remember the gospel is much bigger than any flag. God’s love is for everyone—Americans, Canadians, Chinese, Nigerians, and everyone else.

· Keep the church focused on Jesus. The main message should always be about God’s love and forgiveness, not about politics or national pride.

How Can We Do Better?

Here are some practical steps for churches and Christians:

· Focus worship on God, not the nation. It’s okay to pray for your country, but church services should be about honoring God first.

· Use symbols carefully. There’s nothing wrong with displaying a flag, but the cross should always come first. Make sure that outsiders and newcomers know that God’s family includes everyone.

· Be welcoming to all. Go out of your way to make people from every background feel at home. Don’t assume everyone shares the same politics or nationality.

· Teach history and faith honestly. Don’t pretend that Christianity has always agreed with everything America has done. Be honest about mistakes and open to change.

· Learn from Christians around the world. Listen to stories from believers in other countries. This will open your eyes to the global church and help you see the gospel in a bigger, richer way.

Conclusion: Keeping the Main Thing the Main Thing

At the end of the day, faith is about much more than national pride. Being a Christian isn’t about being American, German, Brazilian, or anything else—it’s about following Jesus and loving God and your neighbor. When we keep the gospel at the center, and the flag in its proper place, the church can be a place where all people are welcome, and where the message of hope and love rings out to the whole world.

So next time you see a flag in church, remember: give thanks for your country, but keep your faith bigger than your flag. God’s family is worldwide, and that’s something worth celebrating.

Notes: