Examining the Challenges Facing Modern Evangelicalism
The question of whether Christianity has become toxic is both challenging and polarizing. Many perceive the Western Church’s approach to social and political issues as ineffective. They feel the heart of faith is overshadowed by agendas. These agendas dilute its core message. This post seeks to explore the factors contributing to this sentiment. It draws from biblical principles, cultural dynamics, and the responsibility of Christ-followers.
Christianity and Its Foundational Ethos
At its heart, Christianity is built upon the Greatest Commandment as stated in Matthew 22:37-40. It teaches to love God with all one’s heart, soul, and mind. Another core teaching is to love one’s neighbor as oneself. Love is the cornerstone of faith. Without love, even the most impressive spiritual gifts and deeds are meaningless. This is emphasized in 1 Corinthians 13:2. It says: “If I had the gift of prophecy, and if I understood all of God’s secret plans and possessed all knowledge, I would be nothing. Even if I had such faith that I could move mountains, but didn’t love others, I would be nothing.”
Yet, in observing the actions of certain evangelical groups, one can wonder whether this principle has been neglected. The belligerent behavior of some leaders and followers within evangelical Christianity has raised concerns. People are worried about whether core biblical values are being discarded. These concerns arise due to the favoring of political and cultural agendas. A toxic environment will develop when pride and self-righteousness replace humility and genuine love, leading to alienation rather than unity.
The Impact of Politics on Faith
Evangelical Christians played a significant role in electing President Trump. Many saw his presidency as either a “miracle of the Lord” or an act of divine intervention. Yet, this alignment with political conservatism has raised questions. To what extent are Christian values compromised in pursuit of political influence? Is there a “seat at the table?”
It is important to pray for leaders. We must also hold them accountable. There is concern that insulating unchristian behavior under the guise of support will taint the witness of the Church. As stated in 2 Chronicles 7:14, a call to humility and repentance is essential. “If my people, who are called by my name, will humble themselves and pray. They should seek my face and turn from their wicked ways. Then I will hear from heaven. I will forgive their sin and will heal their land.” This verse highlights the necessity of self-examination and spiritual renewal, which appears increasingly neglected in some circles.
The Spiritual Drift and Dilution of the Gospel
Throughout Scripture, God’s concern for the human condition is clear. His wish is for love, justice, and reconciliation—principles that should guide the Church. Yet cultural pride and political ideology have led to a growing drift that dilutes the message of the Gospel. The self-righteousness induced by pride stands in stark contrast to authentic Christianity, which calls for humility, repentance, and serving others.
The toxic elements of modern Christianity manifest in segregation within the evangelical world. Race, class, and cultural divides undermine the unity envisioned in Christ. How many people are alienated from faith because they feel judged or excluded?
The labels of “conservative” and “liberal” further complicate matters. These terms are political in origin. Yet, they have seeped into theological discourse. This division detracts Christians from the shared mission of spreading the Gospel. As Paul encouraged the early believers, the focus should stay on Christ rather than ideologies or philosophies that distort faith.
Reflections and Renewed Responsibility
The cultural climate undeniably influences the thinking and actions of the Church. Like the churches addressed in Revelation, modern congregations must stay clear-headed and focused on their mission. The drift toward diluting the Gospel compromises the integrity of mainline churches and alienates those seeking genuine spiritual connection.
The Church of Christ should not justify unchristian behavior. It should not insulate leaders from accountability. Instead, the Church should show grace, power, and anointing that inspires transformation. Imagine a world where evangelicals mirror God’s love in their treatment of outsiders and stewardship of creation. Envision a place where humility replaces pride. Picture service replacing self-righteousness. This vision aligns with the Father’s heart, which is a deep and abiding love for His people and creation.
Conclusion
The question, “Has Christianity become toxic?” serves as a call to introspection and action. While the challenges facing modern evangelicalism are significant, they are not insurmountable. The Church can reclaim its role through humility. Repentance and a renewed commitment to the Gospel are essential. These allow it to become again a beacon of love, justice, and truth in a divided world. As followers of Christ, we must strive to embody His teachings. We make sure that our witness reflects His glory. It should not tarnish it.
Minister A Francine Green
December 2025
afrancinegreen.com 