Faith, Politics, and Identity: Navigating America’s Crossroads

Several years ago, around 2018, I found myself reflecting on the changing landscape of America. At the time, I was concerned about the divisions emerging across the country, but I didn’t fully grasp how deeply some conservative white Christians had become intertwined with right wing conservative politics. As I watched events unfold and listened to public discourse, it became evident that the alliance between faith and political ideology was more entrenched than I had realized. This convergence seemed to influence not only policy and elections, but also the broader culture, fueling passionate debates over values, identity, and the direction of the nation. Looking back, I recognize that my initial concerns only scratched the surface of a complex and enduring shift that continues to shape America today.

What I wasn’t familiar with at the time was the concept of Christian nationalism and the ways in which nationalist ideology could exert influence over both politics and the Church’s public witness. As I learned more, it became clear that Christian nationalism goes beyond mere political engagement, blending religious identity with a vision of America as a distinctly Christian nation. This fusion has threaten the integrity of the Church’s mission, as it prioritizes political power over spiritual values and blurring the line between faith and partisan loyalty. The potential consequences include undermining the Church’s credibility, alienating those who don’t share these views, and distorting the message of Christianity in the public sphere.

Amid this evolving landscape, the rise of Donald Trump and the Republican Party marked a pivotal moment in American politics. Trump’s unconventional approach and populist rhetoric resonated with many voters who felt alienated by traditional political elites, propelling him to the presidency in 2016. Under his leadership, the Republican Party experienced a significant shift, aligning itself more closely with nationalist sentiments, conservative social values, and a combative stance against perceived threats to American identity. This transformation not only redefined the party’s priorities but also energized a new coalition of supporters, amplifying divisions within the country and further intertwining political allegiance with cultural and religious identities.

Around that time, I remember hearing in my spirit the words, “Donald Trump is a rabble rouser.” Honestly, I had no idea what that meant, so I decided to look it up in Webster’s dictionary. I learned that a rabble rouser is someone who stirs up the emotions of a crowd, usually for political reasons, often by appealing to anger or prejudice. That definition made me pause and reflect on how Trump’s style and message seemed to energize and sometimes provoke strong reactions among his supporters and opponents alike. It helped me better understand the impact he was having on the political climate and why his leadership felt so different from what I had seen before.

The past several years have been rocky for America, with the rise of Donald Trump and the growth of Christian nationalism shaking things up. Trump’s bold style and tough talk changed the way politics worked, drawing in people who felt left out or frustrated with the old ways. At the same time, Christian nationalism started to gain more attention, mixing religious beliefs with ideas about what it means to be American. This combination has led to heated discussions, deepening divides between groups, and making it harder for some people to connect or find common ground. Overall, these changes have made the nation’s politics and culture feel more intense and uncertain.

As I reflect on these profound changes, I’m reminded of the importance of humility, empathy, and a commitment to seeking truth amid tumultuous times. The intertwining of faith and politics presents both challenges and opportunities for believers and citizens alike. It calls us to examine our hearts, listen carefully to others, and strive for unity without compromising conviction, all while remembering the greater purpose to which we are called.

Let us pray: God of wisdom and peace, guide our nation through these turbulent times. Grant us the courage to love our neighbors, the discernment to pursue justice, and the humility to seek reconciliation where there is division. May Your spirit empower us to witness faithfully, stand for truth, and embody grace in all we do. Amen.

Minister A Francine Green

February 2026

Notes:

See previous post on Speaking Spiritual Truths: Navigating Through Uncertainty Pt. 2

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.