A Christian reflection on fairness, loving our neighbor, and caring for the vulnerable
When We Think About Fairness
John Rawls asks a thoughtful question: What rules would we choose if we had no idea what kind of life we were going to receive? It is a philosophical question, but it touches something deeply human—and for Christians, something deeply spiritual. Scripture teaches us to love our neighbor as ourselves, to act justly, and to remember those who are easily overlooked. That is one reason this question matters. If we did not know whether we would be strong or weak, comfortable or struggling, we would likely want a world shaped by fairness, mercy, and care for others.
Seeing Others with Humility
Rawls asks us to imagine making society’s rules from behind a “veil of ignorance.” In simple terms, that means we do not know whether we would be rich or poor, healthy or sick, powerful or vulnerable. This picture can help soften the heart. It reminds us that fairness becomes easier to value when we stop assuming we will always be on the strong side of life. As Christians, that kind of humility matters. It helps us look at others with compassion and remember that every person bears dignity before God.
- It teaches humility. We are reminded that we do not know what burdens another person may carry.
- It encourages mercy. Fairness grows when we think beyond our own advantage.
Why Fairness Matters
Rawls calls his idea “justice as fairness” because he believes fair rules come from a fair starting point. Christians may say something similar in everyday life: people are more likely to act justly when they remember their own need for grace. Fairness is not only about systems and laws. It is also about the posture of the heart. A heart shaped by love will care deeply about whether others are treated with dignity, honesty, and compassion.
Two Simple Ideas Worth Remembering
At the heart of Rawls’s idea are two simple reminders:
- Basic rights should belong to everyone. Freedom and dignity should not be reserved for the powerful.
- Differences in wealth or power should never ignore the vulnerable. If a system helps some people while crushing others, something is wrong.
- they improve the situation of the least advantaged people in society, and
- the offices and opportunities connected to them are genuinely open to all under fair conditions.
A Question for the Christian Heart
This is where the conversation becomes personal. It is easy to support fairness when it costs us nothing. But the gospel repeatedly turns our eyes toward the poor, the weak, the outsider, and the forgotten. We are called not only to ask what works for most people, but also to ask what happens to those with the least voice. That does not answer every political question for us, but it does shape the kind of people we should be—people marked by justice, mercy, and neighbor love.
Living This Out
- Pray for eyes to notice those who are often overlooked.
- Ask whether your view of fairness makes room for the vulnerable.
- Let love of neighbor shape how you think about justice.
- Remember that every person carries God-given dignity.
In the end, fairness is not only a public question. It is also a spiritual one. It asks whether our hearts have been shaped by the love, humility, and mercy of Christ.
Closing Reflection
Rawls offers a helpful question: What kind of world would we want if we did not know where we would stand in it? For Christians, that question can become a mirror. It invites us to examine whether our hearts are being shaped by self-interest or by the love of Christ. May God teach us to care about fairness not only when it benefits us, but because we belong to a Savior who sees the lowly, honors the weak, and calls us to love our neighbors as ourselves.
Minister A Francine Green, May 2026
____________________
References
Rawls, J. (1999). A theory of justice (Rev. ed.). The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
Wenar, L. (2012). John Rawls. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2012 ed.). Stanford University.
Duignan, B. (2026, April 10). John Rawls. In Encyclopædia Britannica.